• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Relationship Blackbook

Stronger Connections, Happier Relationships

Search For Articles

  • Marriage & Husband
  • About Me
  • Contact

4 Page Letters And Other Attraction Myths

This past weekend I was hanging out with a male friend of mine and there was a song that started to play on the radio. It was one of the late songstress Aaliyah’s popular tunes, 4 Page Letter.

The lyrics never really stood out to me, especially when I was younger and used to sing along when it came on the radio.

But for some reason, this time I really paid attention to the lyrics and although I like this song, I realized that this was the worst relationship advice anyone could give to a woman.

If you are unfamiliar with the song, here are a few of the lyrics “I Always Had My Eyes, On This One Particular Guy – I Was Too Shy, So I Decided To Write – I’m Sending Him A Four Page Letter”

From this song, it sounds as if Aaliyah doesn’t even know the guy, but is going to spend her time and energy writing him a four page letter!

Alright, I understand that when you start writing sometimes it just flows. I’m a writer, I get that. Sometimes I have a hard time keeping my writings to you guys within a reasonable limit – because there is so much information to share. And it’s easier for me too, since I am typing.

But, this song was written in the 90’s and computer use wasn’t near as popular as it is now. So most likely Aaliyah was going to actually write (with pen and paper) this four page letter to this guy she didn’t know.

Hmmm….What’s wrong with four page letters?

Absolutely nothing, if it’s for a college application or a business proposal or even to write to get your child into a competitive private school. But to write a four page letter to a guy, it’s a little obsessive and a bit scary.

I turned to my guy friend and asked him, if he would like to receive a four page letter from a woman and he said it was a little bit too much and as I asked around, a lot of men just said it was a complete turn off.

Why Four Page Letters Unequivocally Don’t Work

If you’ve been following my lessons, you know that I you not to pursue men. This doesn’t mean that you never talk to men or never have male friendships. This means that you shouldn’t be laying all your cards out on the table and trying to convince him that you are the one.

Men love the chase and if you take that away from him, you have done him and yourself a great disservice. One of the worst feelings in the world is actually being successful at getting the guy that you chased, only to see him turn around and pursue another woman – shy guys do this too.

Most men know how to make the first move – if they’re interested. Let him do that. If you start out chasing a man you will have to continue it throughout the duration of the relationship.

Writing him a letter is just another way of pursuing, “Here I am, Pick Me”.

Let’s Look At the Expectations Here

When you write long letters you are most likely pouring out a lot of feelings and expectations, what you believe your relationship will look like.

These are just your thoughts! You don’t know if he will be the one you want or not, you don’t know him!

You are presenting to him a fairytale that it will be hard to live up to. This scares him. You’ve already placed him on a pedestal, worthy of a four page letter without really knowing him.

And if by a small, minute, mustard seed chance that he is interested in you from your letter, he will quickly fall from your graces because you will realize that he’s not perfect soon enough. And most likely you will be expecting him to show you the same level of interest you showed him.

Well What If I Do Know Him?

Still don’t do it, but this is for another blog post, another day.

Here’s What We Want

Intuitively we know we want the four page letter to come from him, because that would be so romantic, along with a dozen roses and chocolates.

Since women want these things, we make the huge mistake of believing that if we give these things to him, he will give us what we need in return. This is false.

Men are different from women!

Men love the chase. If you are effective at getting him to chase you while giving positive signals, his attraction will increase, and eventually he will do these things for you.

 

Related


Discover more from Relationship Blackbook

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

About Robyn Lee

Robyn Lee is the writer behind Relationship Blackbook, where she’s spent over a decade sharing practical insights to help women build happy, healthy partnerships—while nurturing the most important relationship of all: the one with themselves. Drawing on personal experience, in-depth research, and a passion for real talk, Robyn’s mission is to empower women to create meaningful connections, both in love and in life.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Hannah says

    February 10, 2012 at 10:09 am

    I’d be terrified if a man put me up on a pedestal for the same reasons. I don’t want to always have to be in perfect makeup and lingerie and basically a Playboy bunny or perfect mom type for him. I’m a person, I get grouchy, I have needs, I’m insecure, I stain my clothes sometimes. Give me a break! I’m not Goddess and STILL I deserve love, whadya know.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Behind Relationship Blackbook 💞

Robyn Lee writes about marriage, communication, and building better relationships. Obsessed with research, she combines insights from psychology, renowned relationship experts, and over two years of couples therapy to help women connect with their husbands in ways that actually work.

Learn more about Robyn’s story here.

Join the Inner Circle

I thought I was communicating clearly—but my husband wasn’t hearing me.

Turns out, most women talk to men in "woman language"—and it backfires.

After two years in couples therapy, I learned a better way. Less frustration. More connection. A stronger marriage.

Want to know how? Join my inner circle.

  • About Me
  • Privacy & Terms of Use
  • Contact Me

Copyright © 2025 Relationship Blackbook · All Rights Reserved

 

Loading Comments...
 

    Last Updated on April 26, 2020 by Robyn Lee